I decided today to attend the funeral for Avery Cardinal Dulles, S.J. today at St. Patrick’s Cathedral. The service was chiefly presided over by Edward Cardinal Egan. Some of the co-celebrants were Theodore Cardinal McCarrick, Seán Patrick Cardinal O’Malley, OFM Cap, Fordham President Joseph M. McShane, S.J., Fordham President Emeritus Joseph A. O’Hare, S.J., the Papal Nuncios to the United Nations and United States (I believe I received Eucharist from one of them), and New York Society of Jesus Provincial David S. Ciancimino (a man I have known for about seven years now since he was once the headmaster of Xavier High School) (as well as many other priests, bishops, archbishops, and cardinals).
Strangely missing from the batch, from what I saw (I could be wrong), was the Very Rev. David M. O’Connell. (However, to be fair, he could have been in the audience.)
The mass was not that crowded (I cannot accurately say how many people there were becuase of the sheer size of St. Patrick’s, a lot does not seem as so). I actually got a very good seat (about the 15th row, so about 30 feet from the altar). I saw in the audience, I saw the Law School Dean William M. Treanor.
Egan said that Pope Benedict XVI himself requested for him to perform the mass. (I had not realized how deep a voice Egan had.)
Father C (as we called him) did the Gospel reading. Egan, then, gave the Homily (which, I swear must have been like 30 minutes long), which was an extended obituary. To someone who had not followed Cardinal Dulles’ carear, it would have been interesting; but I have heard it all before. (He also seemed to mess up dates: confusing the 13th with the 12th as the day Dulles died and the 1900s with 1990.) Egan mentioned how Dulles and he (along with McCarrick) were elevated to the College of Cardinals at the same time.
Egan told a story of how this past summer he was invited to a 90th birthday celebration for Dulles. Egan said he was honored to be asked to go. When it came time for the mass at the Fordham Rose Hill Chapel, there was a question of how the procession would go. The presider asked if Egan would be willing to wheel Dulles down the procession. He agreed. However, Egan, too, had polio as a child and, that day, was having leg troubles. When they reached the end, Egan asked Dulles “did you have a bumpy ride?” Dulles smiled (he had lost his ability to talk some time before as a result of the polio he contracted while in the Navy in the 40s).
Egan went through all of his Dulles’ accomplishments and ended that no American priest has even that well accomplished.
The rest of the mass went on as usual. Father C gave the eulogy. He told Cardinal Egan how Cardinal Dulles truly treasured their friendship and how grateful Dulles was for Egan’s constant visits in his final months. He thanked the Dulles family for giving the Jesuits the gift of Avery. He said how Dulles, for all of his accomplishments, was still a brother Jesuit to them. He did his own laundry, made his own breakfast, and helped the rest of them decorate the Christmas tree. It made one realize that though he was a prince of the Church, he was a regular person.
Leaving, I saw the Ram Van (a shuttle between the Fordham campuses) outside St. Patrick’s. I remembered that on Tuesday, the Ram Van was shuttling the Dulles family. However, there were limousines outside. My guess, it was shuttling the Fordham community. Since I had my Fordham ID on me, I considered for a minute to try to catch it (I do not know if they would have let me on because of some other purpose the Ram Van may have been playing). But, since going to any of the campuses would have hindered me heading home, I did not pursue it further.
This morning, I was unsure if I should attend. I asked a friend and my boss if I should go, they said I should. I did not regret it. I saw a piece of history